| Reviews for The Lords of Winter |
|---|
Order of Alignment chapter 34 . 7/7 Had me in the first half, aint gonna lie. |
Imafantotally chapter 2 . 4/1 One word that sums up Catelyn’s personality is bitch. |
miguelgiuliano.co chapter 40 . 3/21 Genial historia espero con ansias por que continúes con ella. Aun espero que Jon posee un harén y se vuelva rey, después de todo un rey puede tomar lo que quiera. |
SEAGUL chapter 21 . 3/3 I thought Trant was already dead, but I must have read it wrong earlier. He must have been one of the only surviving Kingsguard. |
Guest chapter 3 . 2/5 North don’t do knights lol dumb |
Svenion chapter 40 . 12/13/2019 there goes my hope for a concise story |
Svenion chapter 2 . 12/13/2019 YES! you dont know how long I've looked for a story where Cat dies early! so many mistakes and abuses to be avoided! |
Scillacci chapter 40 . 11/14/2019 No Review just a question, are you still out There or is this Story Done ? |
Phoenixsky13 chapter 23 . 7/16/2019 First I just want to say that I have been loving this story and your characterization of Jon Snow and planned to leave a review when I finished it completely but I had to comment on this chapter. It completely took me out of the story to play some coy game. I was excited to read your story and see how this information would add to Jon's story and was also excited to see your spin on it, no matter who his mother was in this AU. If it doesn't matter then you could have left it out completely. But instead this chapter is breaks the proverbial fourth wall so hard that its jarring. |
Foxy-Floof chapter 19 . 6/30/2019 Damn it, Ned Stark! Not everyone follows the rules you do. "Honor. Honor's killed millions of people, never saved a single one." -Jean-Baptiste Emmanuel Zorg (Gary Oldman) *Fifth Element* |
Foxy-Floof chapter 17 . 6/30/2019 Wow... this was good. Really good. You impressed me with how accurate the close combat worked. Just a rush of blood, and violence, and exhaustion. The last couple chapters were excellently done. |
Foxy-Floof chapter 4 . 6/30/2019 Wow... Jon seems happier in this world. I'm glad. Jon always wore a long face, and it didn't suit him well. And this story... well there won't be any angry Catelyn Stark to kidnap Tyrion, so hopefully not the same war between Starks and Lannisters. Likewise, no maternal muddling with betrothals and such. So hopefully no angry vengeful Freys. Also Theon is likely crippled, so maybe no betrayal there... Here's hoping for the best! And bracing for the worst. |
BohemianVoldemort chapter 21 . 6/12/2019 Ser Meryn Trant died fighting in the south, though, right? or was this a different fanfic? |
CamTheThief chapter 40 . 5/7/2019 I hate that I’m almost relieved that this story is apparently abandoned. Only almost because goddamn did I love the first 33 chapters... but now? You’ve introduced the gods as apparently major players in the story, you’ve turned Bran into the most convenient plot device ever to be used whenever you wish (simultaneously turning Jon into little more than a puppet on strings when the man isn’t even allowed to have a goddamn conversation)... even with Dorne getting involved in the story once more I’m loathe to see this tale fall any further... No, strike that. I do want to see this continue. Even with the bizarre and asinine changes in direction, I still like this story. I like Jon and his priorities, I’ve liked 95% of the combat and battle sequences, and I like how different the battle lines are from canon whilst still maintaining the odd similarity. You just need to return to what made this story good. Take a step back from Jon being an agent of the gods, leave that to Bran. Take a step back from manifest destiny and dreamy visions. Let Jon back into the world as the Bloody Wolf. Let him be the ruthless, bad-ass force of nature that gives politics the middle finger and would set the world on fire if it means keeping his family safe. That simple premise is what this story is. These new elements you seem to be introducing only distract from that. They don’t have to, but in their current state they are. |
CamTheThief chapter 39 . 5/7/2019 A hearing to explain his actions to uneducated masses... what? You actually had him explain his dreams? Why would he ever do that? Are they trying to inspire a new wave of religious zealotry? The things you’ve done with this tale belay all sense I swear. |