aww this broke my heart, now we know why he was up that one night crying after his heart attack... i feel happy and sad at the same time :)

That ending was completely unexpected but absolutely perfect. Thank you for such a beautifully written story!

OH. MY. GOSH. That ending was SO unexpected, and I'm so happy right now. I'm grinning like an idiot. I need more stories about Beth and the Doctor and their travels. Omg... This story was so GOOD!

This story was incredible! Probably my favorite of all your stories I've read so far. I didn't pick up on the twist until the heart attack (like you intended). I loved the AU part of the story before that point as well as the final resulting story. Excellent writing! And I can't wait for the next update on your current story (another favorite)!

You've written John's love so beautifully.

I love your story sooo sooooo much!

Wonderful ending 3

This was my sweet escape during this holidays.

Bittersweet.

Thank YOU for writing this.

:)

Great story. Great ending:)

Great ending, unexpected and well written...I liked it a lot :) Good work, as always :D

This was beautiful! Thank you so much for writing this story I've enjoyed it every day.

The ending is beautiful. I've been reading this story since you released the first chapter and was never disappointed. Well done!

:(

I wonder if John ever told Clara some of his past life with more details. It should have been the fair thing to do. Beautiful story you've written. Thank you.