| Reviews for Rose Lily Potter -- Metamorphmagus-Who-Lived |
|---|
zenon the overlord chapter 2 . 1/28 I know someone who tends to fall sleep after eating sweets to. |
automaton14 chapter 7 . 10/11/2019 wtf no |
Guest chapter 17 . 8/9/2019 Harry Potter was the best and you made it horrible |
ElyseSyrova chapter 19 . 7/25/2019 I wonder, ought there be a distinction drawn in that sort of class between shock-horror and deep-seated, persistent terror? One can strike pretty easily, and catch one short. The other keeps one from sleep and grinds away at resolve and reserves. Hence, James's fear of Lilly's loss, and Roses shocked and horrid surprise. Just a thought from reading several variants of boggart scenes. |
ElyseSyrova chapter 16 . 7/25/2019 That's another thing. The conspiracy charge was "pardoned"? The Potters ought have refused and forced either a verdict upon or an recinsion of the charge. Accepting a pardon requires, de rigueur and de jure, an acknowledgement of guilt of the misdeeds being pardoned. They are maintaining their innocence, and thus have the right to refuse a pardon in favor of being acknowledged by their society and peers as blameless. Fudge offering to pardon them is an obvious trap, which Ted should have caught easily and reversed on him, turning to bite the Minister on the arse. Frankly, Fudge deserves it just for allowing the charge to be brought in the first place. |
ElyseSyrova chapter 16 . 7/25/2019 If it happened outside of British jurisdiction, then no British judiciary has any standing whatsoever to bring any charges at all, regardless the citizenship of the accused. The charges about illicit magic use are a complete no-go from the start, and should have been moved to be dismissed immediately on those grounds. That is just a preposterous overreach, for which the Ministry should be spanked. Hard. |
ElyseSyrova chapter 15 . 7/25/2019 Wait. You've been talking up until this point as if Rose is the heir, but now it's Charlie? Whuh? That makes lots of things you've written so far not work, e.g. the duel challenge from Heir Malfoy to Heir Potter, which was reasoned out from on grounds of needing the consent of both heads of house to proceed _because_ they were both the heirs of house. Kinda strong dissonance there. |
Aweesome chapter 21 . 7/24/2019 Like your story it's unfortunate that you had to use this witches secret as an excuse for some action since it doesn't make sense if you have to have magic inside you to get magical children, there would be no Muggleborn or squips and it doesn't feel right. and there shouldn't be rules against masturbation. that's basically rape if it's not allowed to do it themselves you are forcing them to have someone go down on them. well if you don't consider all this it's pretty good well i can't read this without thinking about my daughter or other little girls suffering this. so i'll stop reading |
Riptide115 chapter 28 . 7/11/2019 I love you story. Are you going to continue it? |
Zekrob chapter 28 . 4/20/2019 Two questions: What happened that Susan and Hermione did not find Neville? Will you be picking this story back up at some point, considering it has been untouched for multiple years at this point, and I really like this story |
Fairy King Oberon chapter 1 . 4/2/2019 pity you abandoned this story, it looked really interesting. ah well, can't expect every good idea to be followed through on. |
RaiderDRY chapter 17 . 3/29/2019 Greek mythology |
RaiderDRY chapter 17 . 3/29/2019 Artemis is the goddess of the Moon Selene is the Titan Goddess of the Moon |
spacecowboy2011 chapter 1 . 3/20/2019 Yes, chapter 28 was posted. Over 3 years ago. Might want to update the description so it doesn’t read as if you’ve recently updated. Just a suggestion. |
maxii.caulfieldx chapter 4 . 1/3/2019 Acting soundtrack licenser here Echosmith- Surround (towards the end) Again, love the story! |