| Reviews for Piper Rose Halliwell |
|---|
   K.C.96 chapter 21 . 9/3/2019 Honestly, I think it would over-complicate things as a big part of Earth-who happens there. At least with Rose. Piper having grown up somewhere else? That's not much of a problem, maybe her grandmother lives in London, or they ended up moving there for some reason. But what about the Tyler family? Why would they live there (where ever it would be), and why would at least Rose be in London? Also, Rose kinda seems like a city-girl to me (and I'm admitting my bias as a female who was born and raised in a village in the country side, and isn't much for the city.) Still, that's just my opinion, if you want to go through this then I'll look forwards to seeing how it all plays out. Btw, love the Story line and I can't wait to find out how SPN plays into it. Sadly I'm not one for commenting that often, so you might not hear from me all that much. |
| the stargate time traveller chapter 21 . 8/20/2019 Go for it. |
| ShelBell25 chapter 20 . 7/31/2019 Can't wait to see what you will do! |
| AlphaF34R chapter 19 . 5/9/2019 I realize this is probably dead but I really wish it wasn't especially when it was about to get better. |
| RoseMeg1 chapter 1 . 12/14/2018 *pout* I want more it is so good. I want to know what will happen |
| The Jabberwocky High Priestess chapter 19 . 9/22/2018 Love the story, but are you ever going to come back to it? |
| RitzChan chapter 19 . 6/22/2018 omg, this is starting to get so good ... and yes, leave rose at home for now, it's time for some angel godness |
| cphfflover chapter 19 . 5/10/2018 please update |
| AnimeLuvr96 chapter 19 . 8/12/2017 I hope you didn't give up on this, it's really good and I'm dying to see how Piper reacts to 10. |
| SnowKi chapter 19 . 7/13/2017 more pleaz |
| Alaria von Raven chapter 19 . 4/17/2017 I am addicted I need more please update soon |
| GayMexicanBatman chapter 19 . 2/25/2017 PLEASE UPDATE SOON THIS IS FREAKING AMAZING! |
| the stargate time traveller chapter 19 . 2/7/2017 I see your point about Rose being a little too quick to accept the new Doctor. The problem is when Doctor Who came back in 2005, I thought she was good for him, it wasn't until later I saw she was a handful and a bit overrated. Here in your story, there have been moments that show Piper being a more mature woman in comparison. The fact she would suddenly judge him compared to the 9th Doctor is unfair - how does she know what her old Doctor would or wouldn't do; he might have regenerated but he's got the same basic personality. The only criticism I have is he didn't confront her for the things she had said when he was unconscious. I can't wait to read more. Take care. |
| Metaphorical Tables chapter 19 . 2/4/2017 eeeuuuuurghhhh piper isn't schizophrenic i hope she ends up okay |
| Metaphorical Tables chapter 18 . 1/31/2017 im concerned for piper shes hearing angel radio, isn't she |
