| Reviews for A New Life Part 1 |
|---|
Courtesy Trefflin chapter 1 . 6/24 I loved this story! I've always liked reading stories where Vader survives the Death Star. |
L chapter 1 . 6/7 At least he didn't kill half the galaxy with a person accompanying him saying "Rejoice, for in death your worthless lives have meaning". That was messed up. |
mayawene chapter 1 . 1/25 Thanks for this story ! ! ! ! It make me cry |
Order66WithFries chapter 1 . 9/10/2019 To be honest it got a tad bit annoying because Anakin kept of calling Luke ‘Son.’ Other that that... GOOD JOB! *thumbs up* |
acetwolf94 chapter 1 . 1/26/2019 I LOVE IT! ADD MORE PLEASE! |
Dashusi4ka chapter 1 . 11/22/2016 shmoopy! so shmoopy, I can't even, omg! I think I'm developing cavities from this story alone, ugh. at the same time I don't dislike it. huh. oops? |
VioletErin.26 chapter 1 . 11/21/2016 Yay. Beautiful. So cool how Luke managed to get his father back. Wow. Really impressive. Love reading about their emotions. While I don't really like Leia I can understand her reluctance towards Anakin. Nice to see Hans pov. |
guest chapter 1 . 5/19/2016 Great story! |
jess chapter 1 . 3/25/2013 I know it's been 11 years, but id like to read more :) |
MysticalKC chapter 1 . 1/4/2013 Amazing! I love it! :D Can't wait to read part 2! :) |
Jedi1952 chapter 1 . 11/29/2012 While I like the story, which I just reread, I have to agree with Emalin and Crush48. It is well written, but goes a bit over the board on emotions for these strong characters. |
Exigence chapter 1 . 6/2/2011 Hi, Just came across this story. I like it alot but...Luke and Anakin seem heavily OOC at times. They seem super sensitive emotionally, and in my opinion, Luke comes off a bit more feminine than the Movie's potrayal. Good Story, and I like the plot and word structures. It's just a bit too much with the way Anakin's personality is potrayed. |
2wingo chapter 1 . 1/14/2010 Now THAT was a good story. |
Emalin chapter 1 . 6/17/2008 Again, some very good insights, and some cute moments! (I wuv Wicket!) My advice for "Salvation" applies here as well. There's one other thing I noticed here, though: while "Salvation" covers an emotional scene where sundry conflicting feelings are expected, one right after the other, this scene seems to have too many of those. For a while I felt like I was being jerked around. Much of it is due to the fact that this fic digs into the characters' minds - which is a compelling thing, but there's always a danger of digging so deeply into the emotional aspect that the reader drowns. There's also a danger of characters slipping OOC; Anakin and Luke did that quite often here. I understand you're trying to portray the closeness of their father/son bond, as well as their reactions to its newness. As a whole, however, they came off as "emo" or "touchy-feely", and at the expense of their strong movie personalities. (If I remember correctly, Luke doesn't cry once during the entire saga, except for when Anakin dies at the end. Even then, he didn't break out sobbing. For that reason, I can't see Luke as crying that often, even after Anakin has been restored to him. If you think he would experience a whirlwind of emotion during this time, try drawing attention to the fact that his emotions are "in a whirlwind". That way, it wouldn't make it seem like he's ALWAYS like that. Same for Anakin.) Now, I understand you have your own vision of the characters, and I hope I don't come across as harsh in my criticism. I offer it kindly. :) We can keep discussing it, if you like. |
FireChildSlytherin5 chapter 1 . 5/30/2007 Great one-shot. :) |