| Reviews for Honor And Fealty |
|---|
mlkoolc86 chapter 25 . 2/18 I understand about personal life take your time. Seeing the update made me go back to the beginning and made me rediscover why I enjoyed this story so much. If you are asking for suggestions I would say maybe after the baby is born. Look forward to the next one but at the same time no rush take care of yourself first! |
Knight Revan chapter 25 . 2/18 I found this 2 days ago and have taken a great liking to it. I do have a few criticisms which aren't dealbreakers (this is fanfiction after all) but they could do with some explanations. It seems to me that people are travelling at an unprecedentedly fast rate, especially in the North. From Winterfell they can go in any direction and reach the furthest destination in a single day which doesn't make much sense because the North is larger than the entire south of Westeros. I get that you wanted Renly and the Tyrells to interact with the northern party as a plot device but there is no logical reason why or how the stormlords and reachmen would end up on the north side of the Green Fork and cross the Twins to reach Riverrun. They would simply come up from the south. Also you said earlier that you weren't well versed in writing for relationships but I do have issues with the way the romantic ones are being portrayed. Dacey and especially Lyra have been extremely sexual in their pursuits of Robb and Jon. In context of George Martin's world I highly doubt the honorable Eddard Stark would be in any way pleased by their behavior or Robb and Jon's. That also leads to questions of Jon. For a bastard that has never wanted to sire another bastard he doesn't seem to have much of an issue taking things further with Lyra. I loved the early chapters of this story. But when these issues started popping up when the Mormonts all came to Winterfell, it was a bit hard to ignore them. This is some simple constructive criticism to help things. Regardless, I enjoy this story and hope it continues. The Mormonts as a family are rarely featured so heavily in fanfics which makes this very intriguing and unique. |
Marah Lane chapter 25 . 2/17 Oh I am so happy you updated! I totally understand about life getting in the way. You handled Walder Frey well, his characterization was well done. I like the subtle nods the better Freys, especially Olyvar as I have a soft spot for him. And loved the introduction of Brienne The little bit of political intrigue there was a nice touch. Both Dacey and Robb did well. I do hope this leads to a good friendship or at least some sort of alliance with Renly as I always thought those two would be good allies. Cannot wait to read more! As for the pregnancy thing...I kind of like the idea of an heir being already born when Robert arrives to show the strength of House Stark. |
jean d'arc chapter 25 . 2/16 Good chapter! Glad to have you back :) Thanks |
Wika0304 chapter 24 . 2/4 please update, it's brilliant |
chinalatina28 chapter 13 . 11/10/2019 I don't see what Lyra did wrong. She made her intentions toward Jon clear. Everyone knew ahead of time. Why get angry *after* she did what she told people she intended to do. If they didn't want her to hook up with Jon the proper time to intervene is before it happens. He consented and and Lyra didn't even tell him what to do |
HaywireEagle chapter 1 . 9/26/2019 Surprised Aemon didn't hit her with the whole "I am of the south as well?" and knock her on her proverbial ass. Especially if she makes some comment about Rheagar. It would have been interesting to see. |
AraelDranoth chapter 3 . 5/12/2019 On second viewing... A well written chapter. Keep up the good work. |
AraelDranoth chapter 24 . 5/4/2019 I... like the story though I did feel it went off on several tangents it didn't need to. |
AraelDranoth chapter 7 . 5/4/2019 Good story. I'm not too much of a fan of the events set in the past with Lyanna and Ned but I'm assuming it's critical to the plot. |
AraelDranoth chapter 5 . 5/4/2019 Mormonts and Starks. You don't get more North than that. |
dragonfox123 chapter 1 . 1/24/2019 Interesting chapter and plot and idea |
DarkDesh chapter 24 . 7/26/2017 Great story so far the Starks and Mormonts have always been my favorite and I wondered why there weren't more stories about them. Keep up the good work can't wait to see what happens. |
Marah Lane chapter 24 . 5/17/2017 Okay...so I missed this update, never got an alert for it :/ Oh the tension between Loras and Willas...Loras is being a bit of an arse. Granted he always was kind of childish. Good job on Dacey's part for overcoming her natural reactions to Southroners. It will be interesting to see where Margaery's relationships with the various Northerners will go. Good job with Robb's reaction to Renly too. Looking forward to that Frey meeting |
jean d'arc chapter 24 . 5/10/2017 Good chapter. I liked the interaction between the Tyrell brothers. And I'm glad Dacey is letting go of her prejudice and pre conceived ideas, and keeping an open mind regarding Margaery... Glad to have you back :) |