| Reviews for Who does that? |
|---|
Dimac99 chapter 1 . 1/13 Yep. If I'm honest, I liked *elements* of the later seasons, but they were just handled so poorly and characters behaved very inconsistently without good reason I'm not sure if this fic shouldn't be filed under Tragedy instead! |
Joan Powers chapter 1 . 11/5/2019 Love that last line. So true, so many plot devices at that point were so contrived. |
JavaJunkieGermany chapter 1 . 11/5/2017 I'm laughing so hard right now! :D THIS was adorable! And OMG are you right! Who in the freakin hell does that? Very good read :D Thank you! I'm totally checking your other stuff out :) Have a great day! Julia :* |
PurryCat chapter 1 . 11/21/2016 Rereading the first part of the Winthrop Women trilogy in anticipation of the GG revival left me again totally enchanted, entertained and satisfied. Dirty! |
Guest chapter 1 . 4/23/2016 Loved it! Wish you could have been script supervisor on the show. |
complete-randomalities chapter 1 . 1/18/2016 I still love this XD |
complete-randomalities chapter 1 . 11/17/2015 This has to be one of the best Gilmore Girl AU things I have ever read! It's the best and I love it! |
Fish Bag chapter 1 . 5/8/2015 Yes! Yes! Yes! I love absolutely every. single. word. But I think my favorite line, if I had to narrow it down, would be the one about "some writer making a show tank because they left their integrity in another purse." Yep. And thank you for including the end of season 5 and (especially) season 6 in your brilliant massacre. I get so frustrated when people think season 7 was the shark jumping year. The characters were ruined long before that. Thank you SO MUCH for writing and sharing this! |
fox24 chapter 1 . 5/8/2015 That was funny. Don't agree about Logan and dome other stuff but still well written |
TL22 chapter 1 . 5/8/2015 This is brilliant. Well written and a pleasure to read. |
lulu1960 chapter 1 . 5/8/2015 Hee. Cute. Definitely had pod people in the latter seasons. Funny take on the situation. |
Musical Redhead chapter 1 . 5/8/2015 The meta-humor is really appreciated. I think my favorite line is when Rory sums things up nicely, about inconsistencies for the sake of cheap plot drama. Isn't that the truth? Didn't anyone on that set have a binder with the character backstories? Creative limitation isn't a bad thing. Luke had to have been with Anna (a girl he almost married) the same time he was with Rachel, his very serious girlfriend (?); and his meeting/involvement with Lorelai before the series is so murky. ASP could have easily put a wig on Sherrylynn Fenn as a recasted Rachel, and have her come in S6 with a five year old kid if she absolutely HAD to have a long-lost kid plot. At least then we would have been in on it, and we know he actually had feelings for Rachel. Anna did not come across as a romantic rival to Lorelai. This stuff all came out of nowhere. |
DSLeo chapter 1 . 5/8/2015 Thank you all for the great comments and feedback! Heck, I may rework another moment/series of moments at this rate. I have no idea if I can strike humor gold, but I will mine the dribs of inspiration jotted into my journal and see what springs forth. Again, thank you all so much! |
Droolia chapter 1 . 5/8/2015 I loved it. While I didn't think that last couple seasons of the show were as bad as you did, I did appreciate your brutal, but hilarious honesty. It was great that you used the gang from SH to trash their alternate reality. |
junienmomo chapter 1 . 5/7/2015 Is it too soon to tell you I love you? In the space of several hundred words you've turned the dark seasons into the absolute parody they should have been from the beginning. Please find a couple more moments to rework. We need your kind around here. God, what I wouldn't give for those last seasons to have been a Bob Newhart-like dream sequence. Your TV show is a great response. |