Reviews for My Stars and Your Valleys
PanpaVixen chapter 11 . 6/5
love this its jus so good thank you so much
rattle-the-stars chapter 11 . 5/6
IM IN TEARS THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR WRITING THIS I CANT-
ok but actually i cannot form words right now i love this so much thank you thank you thank you
i stumbled across this yesterday at like 10:44 pm and i stayed up almost all night reading and...
IT WAS SO WORTH IT AND JUST
JUST
aaaaAAAAAAAAA IM FANGIRLING MY GUTS OUT
DragonGrrl539 chapter 4 . 12/24/2019
Overall, I think this is a well-written and very creative sci-fi take on RotG. However, there's something I do want to complain about, as someone who's half-Australian: Bunny's habit of calling Tooth "sheila". Although Outback Steakhouse uses it on their bathroom doors, "sheila" is actually a somewhat derogatory term for a woman, akin to the American "broad". I just wanted to clear that up.
katrum chapter 1 . 7/29/2019
Very intriguing! I'm digging this fic so far - very promising plot :) Onwards, to chapter 2!
Everything4Everyone chapter 11 . 7/25/2019
This is amazing! A truly wonderful and heartfelt tale that inspires both tears and laughter! Great job!
Guest chapter 11 . 5/25/2019
this is hands down the best fanfiction I have ever read- I truly appreciate this story! It's extremely well written and I know it's been a while since it's been published but I just wanted to message this. You have a (natural or built either way) beautiful skill for writing and as a person who reads quite often- I thought I was reading a young adult novel. Thank you for this fic it was awesome!
Madkatt chapter 11 . 1/11/2019
OH MY THIS WAS FANTASTIC! I really loved the world you crafted and would love to see a sequel if you ever come back to this - even if its just a few oneshots about life on board the ship, or the guardians monthly meeting, or the other guardians meeting Maggie and finding out the kids stayed with Jack... things like that. Anyway amazing fic!
Summerstorm chapter 7 . 11/19/2018
IKR? I want to be an Atmospheric Exoplanetary Scientist for NASA in the future. #Pluto4Planet
Happythanksgivin chapter 4 . 11/19/2018
Such a Good Sci-fi story! Thank you!
Nellie O chapter 11 . 8/23/2018
And we finally come back full circle. Maggie! Clever, strong Maggie. I loved that Maggie did just fine for herself, and Jack acknowledged her strength. It's so easy to see how much Jack wants her to come with him, but Maggie has to give him a hard time of course.

I think they'll all be awesome together, flying out in the stars. Jack is pilot of course, with Jamie as copilot. Mags gets to be ship nurse, and patches all these knuckleheads up when they get into trouble. Hmmm... I think Pippa ends up in charge of inventory and scheduling jobs, and is quite the taskmaster. I think Monty would make a great ship chef, and make sure everyone is eating. And Sophie would be Mags' and Monty's secret weapon, because no one can resist med check ups or food when Sophie is asking them.

I'm also imagining a scene early after this where the Guardians find out that some of the kids sent to Jack's planet just, somehow, mysteriously, never made it there? And asking Jack about it at their first meeting. Jack straight up denies everything. "No idea what you're talking about. All kids made it home." Mags, exasperated, punches him in the shoulder, and then they're interrupted when the door crashed open. Sophie tumbles into the room, giggling, and leading a frantic line of Yetis chasing after her.
Guardians: -look at Jack-
Maggie: -eyebrow raised, looks at Jack-
Sophie: -giggles-
Jack: "... They're where they are WANTED, okay? I'm pretty sure we established before that home is where your family is, right?" He's not looking at anyone as he says this.
Then the Guardians agree that clearly, they're are no missing children. They're clearly all back at their homes, safe and sound. And if there is a twinkle in North's eye, or a tear in Tooth's, no one mentions it.

So, just a little scene I was thinking about for after this. It... got a little longer than I expected. Oh well.

Thank you for sharing this story with us! I really enjoyed it, and I really enjoyed giving you feedback on it. Now I'm off to browse your other stories - or at least bookmark them for another day. "Guardian of Guardians" looks to be a great read.

Thanks again!
Nellie
Nellie O chapter 10 . 8/23/2018
They're finally safe! Jack finally has a place among the Guardians, and his own ship, and Jack's going to kidnap a few kids, nbd. I'm really happy for him.

On to the last chapter! I'm so excited!
Nellie O chapter 9 . 8/23/2018
Awesome chapter! Jamie was amazing fighting back, and Jack's learning new things about his powers.

Also, Manny. Huh. Didn't expect that, though I probably should've. He's just as much of an odd figure here as he is in the movie.

Fifty kids on one space ship! Hehehehehe. :) I somehow think Jack's going to handle that way better than the rest of them.

Thanks for sharing this story with us! I'm headed to the next chapter.
Nellie O chapter 8 . 8/23/2018
Ohhh, what a chapter! What a rollercoaster of moods! The Guardians finding out about Jack and Pitch, Pitch's little monologue of evil, and Jamie and Sophie! Eeeee! Jack's gotta go back and save them now. After all, he promised he'd be there, right? :)

Good job on changing Pitch's motivations to suit this AU. It doesn't make him any less creepy and twisted, but I like bad guys with reasons.

Thanks for sharing this! On to the next chapter!
Nellie O chapter 7 . 8/23/2018
Leprechauns! So cool! But poor children.

The disappearing people thing was well done. Jack kept mentioning it throughout the story 'till it became fact for me, and so I felt Jack's disbelief when the Guardians didn't know.

And we finally get backstory behind the scar. Now I understand why Jack became so withdrawn and why he struggled to smile for Mags - he was feeling guilty that whole time. Poor Jack. Poor Maggie.
Nellie O chapter 6 . 8/23/2018
Good action scene! Had me on the edge of my seat. Bunny and Jack work well together, don't they?

Thanks for sharing with us! Moving on to the next chapter!
193 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »