You really put them through some serious "whumping". I love that, thank you very much. Loved the story.

I'm not a hundred percent sure, but this story might be my favourite among your stories (or at least this far). One the one hand it's always tough to read about strife between our heroes but on the other hand this was so well written, it really resonated with my feelings. I might have cried while reading the first chapter, so much tension and suffering).
As always the h/c was very much appreciated and even more so was the reconciliation and the knowledge that everything turned out for the best. Gosh, I love happy endings!
And your stories - they are amazing!

great story! Wounds of the heart or soul can be so much harder to heal . . . i loved the interactions between everyone throughout this story. Your writing is beautiful and rings true to their characters and relationships. It's so great to have had the opportunity to read this.

I just have to pause here and say "sinking ship!" - after everything else you have done to them, now this! You are an evil, mad genius! How does this stuff come out of your brain. I'm so impressed. . and now I have to go finish the rest of the story because part of me is dying inside ...dying!

Absolutely a beautiful story! So true to the characters and the show but more so incredibly written and so full of life and empathy!

Truely great work!

I've never been a fan of the Musketeers show nor have I known much about the actual story. I was just roaming FF for a good story, and you somehow popped up, I'm literally enthralled and overwhelmed, your talent in writing is incredible to have moved me so when I have no background to the characters or main story. Can't wait to dive into your work!

I realise that you wrote this story a while ago but I've only just discovered it.I thought that it was a deeply moving tale full of teriffic h/c.I especially love the way in your writing you don't forget when your characters are hurting and what the repurcussions of aggravating their problems are.I also think that the way you write the relationship between the men is very loved it,please write more.

Wonderful all around whumping/angst fest ! :-D
Luved it, of course ! ;-)

Hmmm... how come when one character asks, "What happened?" another answers by asking, "What do you remember?"

d'Artagnan will have quite the collection of scars to show off later.

Very well done, CelticGal.

Something tells me none of the guys will want to be on a boat anytime soon.

Was glad d'Artagnan was willing to take Pritchard with him to a watery grave. Surrounded by carved wood... yep, sounds like a coffin to me.

Athos' line about wine being involved was very good.

Me thinks someone is about to get wet!

If I could reach through my computer screen and into this story, I would strangle Athos right now. Stupid man.

It's about time those knuckle-heads all figured out they'd better fix things.

Athos doesn't strike me as the type to be a very patient patient. Nope, not gonna happen.