| Reviews for Mistaken Damsel |
|---|
Rumjunkie chapter 10 . 6/28 This is slow and boring for the sake of it. 10 whole chapters to swim down and get a person. Holy shit that's almost impressive in itself. |
Can't sign in chapter 20 . 4/2 Thanks for an interesting tale. I enjoyed it. |
Can't sign in chapter 13 . 3/31 I am pretty sure that in one of the later books, Hermione played in a friendly quidditch game with Harry and some Weasleys. I think it was DH |
Critical reader chapter 20 . 3/15 I'm impressed and take my hat off to you. Finally a story that makes the characters appear as fairly normal people despite their magic, one that does not call upon spectacular (and at the same time cliched) plot devices, one that does not rely on drawn-out action scenes, one that gives depth to the characters, too, by showing what they think. It took a little while to get used to your story, but in a good sense, because it stands out from the background of many variations of a few themes. Yours is a theme unto itself. As for "dramatis personae", I like your introspective and optimistic Ron best, closely followed by your assertive Ginny. |
Guest chapter 20 . 3/9 Really NOT BAD AT ALL! One piece of advice. If you let it the creeps on this site will chew you up and spit you out and go right on to their next target. You have some talent for writing and this site is a good place to develop it much further. The thing is that the points that make it good for your development are the same that can drag you down. The world of professional writers is littered with critics that think they could have done better. A few have some good points, but you MUST grow a thick skin. This ain't real life, folks. It's fantasy practice. Thanks for finishing and leaving us a good read. You can't do much better here. |
Axccel chapter 10 . 3/11 Man this is going to backfire on Skeeter beautifully. |
Axccel chapter 5 . 3/11 Ahhh, but to disqualify Harry for rescuing whom he would miss most would mean every other champion would have to be disqualified for the same reason. Unless the judges intend to officially proclaim they have the right and power to dictate what other peoples’ relationships are. Without even informing said people of said relationships, no less. |
Axccel chapter 3 . 3/11 This is very well-written. |
nashtah chapter 20 . 3/8 thank you for this story. I found it a good read. |
Cassandra30 chapter 20 . 3/8 Excellent ending! |
Cassandra30 chapter 19 . 3/8 Hard for Hermione and Victor. They are a good couple ! Real pity about Olympe. |
aradia1967 chapter 19 . 3/3 really loving this story please update soon |
Charlee56 chapter 19 . 3/1 Olympe did this to herself. Can't be helped now. But Viktor coming out to Hermione as truly wanting her in his life, to the point of offering sanctuary to her extended unofficial family as well as her parents; well, that is simply remarkable! We haven't heard the last of Krum! |
Cassandra30 chapter 18 . 2/11 Excellent chapter! |
mckertis chapter 18 . 2/10 1. Five years, and still you failed to deliver on the premise. 2. Different viewpoints are well and good, but some characters are not worth the time, and dont bring anything interesting to the table. 3. Constant stream of answering every review is fucking obnoxious. Get a bloody forum and do it there. |