Terrific story!

liked it. tho a little thick on poetry and lore about a tree

This is a great story man and I appreciate that you haven’t given up on it!

Harry is a kind of Jesus-like figure isn't he? He comes from another realm and through immense pain and trials, gives hope to others in a world marred by evil (Glorfindel says that seeing Harry not giving up on life after his time in Angmar gave him strength so there must be others who feel the same). He brings together people who were once close in their fight against the Dark Lord but who are now divided.

Still so great! Thanks for all the hard work.

This is better than I expected well done looking forward to more

eru iluvatar

You’re story here is amazing as everyone else has been saying. I’m already eagerly awaiting the next installment. I have slightly delved into lotr lore after the films and it’s awesome to recognize a few of the characters and places I read about back then. I hope we see some more of the blue wizards as time goes on. I’m sure you’ve already considered this but I feel the need to say it. Harry seems to have traveled farther for longer than anyone else bar possibly the Istari. If anyone knows where the Entwives are it’s him. The plight of the ents was always one of the saddest parts of middle earth for me. I’d love if you’d help him

Awesome work

Wow, what a great story! The writing style really resembles the original books. You've really nailed the sense of mystique and wonder in the world that made The Lord of the Rings so great. Look forward to reading more!

I love this story so much! I reread it every time I come back to it. I think this is my third or fourth reread. Right now this is really helping me get through some rough times. So, thank you.
Please keep up the great work!
And stay healthy too!

This is a great story and I am extremely impressed by the authors dedication to canon while still willing and able to write his own story within it. I very much look forward to the next chapter in this tale.

I look forward to new chapters SO much...I always get "settled" with a glass of wine. I want to really ENJOY the new chapter.
I fell in love with LOTR in the 70s, when I was a shy, quiet, nerdy kid, and chose "The Hobbit" for a high-school book project, having no idea of the journey it would send me on. I made a diorama of Smaug's cave, with the Dwarven halls, the piles of (fake!) gems and gold, back-lit with colored holiday lights, the tiny hobbit standing before the terrifying, magnificent dragon, the whole shebang. (Got a A hundred-zillion on it. I'm a professional artist nowadays. Got a degree and everythin'.)

I became a bit obsessed with it. I had posters on my wall, I was DESPERATE to see Bakshi's cartoon...
Tolkien can't give us tales any more, but I've enjoyed this story you're writing so VERY much. I want to thank you for that. Nowadays, I work with kids who have disabilities, and their lives are SO difficult, so unfair. Your protagonist was thrown into a situation not of his making, he knew such misery and loneliness, but he eventually came to be comfortable in his skin, to have friends, to find his feet. I'd wish that for my bunch.

I have no knowledge of lotr so this has been a struggle to say the least. (Lots of wikis and googling) but it's really good and I'll be sticking around for the rest.

This story is so satisfying. Keep up the great work