| Reviews for Harry Potter and the Obsidian Tome |
|---|
Child of Dreams chapter 15 . 1/1/2012 Kevin, could you please explain just why, in the name of God's sweatiest pair of gym socks, does that Irish drinking song about Ron's love for Hermione remind me of the children's song about Zacchaeus? |
Child of Dreams chapter 5 . 1/1/2012 PLEASE PUT IN AN IRISH DRINKING SONG! THOSE ARE THE BEST! |
Child of Dreams chapter 3 . 1/1/2012 Erm, Mr. Weasley's name is Arthur, not Arnold. Is your real name Rita Skeeter? |
David Fishwick chapter 22 . 3/10/2009 Excellent and thanks for writing. |
TheLiteraryMathematician chapter 20 . 6/29/2008 i dont see why people dont like Maths. Its AWESOME! my favorite subject too. Right after English. I like your story, by the way! |
David Fishwick chapter 11 . 1/17/2008 Interesting stuff and please update soon. |
TigerLily Padfoot chapter 3 . 5/22/2004 I liked the letter from Uncle Vernon. That was funny. Isn't Mr. Weasley's name Arthur? You said Arnold, but that might be just a typo. I likle this story just as well as I liked the first two, and hope you continue. |
CrashCart9 chapter 22 . 4/6/2004 Ahh! Need... sequel...! More.. writing... now...! Yeah, you've got like 20 stories here already, so I'll be busy for a while, almighty awesome writery one. Don't worry about killing Draco, I don't know why so many people like his character, maybe he is part veela and can transfer the charm through the book... But the movie now, definetly there, Tom Felton, YUM! But I digress. So, stories, awesome, read this whole trilogy now, terrific, more please. One more thing: DON'T GET A HOBBY! We won't get stories as often as you update then, maybe not ever, so don't start working on model trains or putting any energy whatsoever into your studies or anything. Next come the parodies, but not now, it's 11:36 on a school night. See what you've made me do, I've been on reading your stuff for 3 hours, 21 minutes, and 19 seconds and I have an exam day after tomorrow! Alexandria PS. Not that it's your fault, I wouldn't be studying anyway. |
CrashCart9 chapter 3 . 4/6/2004 Inconsistant (sp?) chapter length, so what? You are like GOD! You can do anything you want as long as you keep putting out chapters! Alexandria Harry's got a friend for the summer! |
Xan chapter 22 . 3/28/2003 Okay, I have to say that ... I think you are one of the best HP writers there are :D. I'm serious. This story (well, this entire trilogy I mean, but I don't feel like submitting 60 reviews, so this is a review of the entire thing. Sort of.) is one of the best I've read, and one of the few that I would consider worth re-reading. And by 'few', I mean that I can count them on one hand. I actually read the ENTIRE trilogy in one sitting (no I'm not crazy, and I really did!) because it was just gripping. So, because of my brilliant reading pace, I might have missed a few things ... but when I'm bored I often end up re-reading fanfic anyway. *shrug* So, anyway, back to the point: This is one heck of a story. Well-written, interesting plot (not to mention subplots) and all the characters are well-rounded and human (by this I mean that they make mistales, have flaws, etc ... everything but a Mary-Sue). This really kept me at the edge of my seat (by the way, my brother thanks you for making me hog the computer ;) j/k). I say this again, thie is one of a very small bunch of fics that I really like. I doubt I'll find a trilogy that's as good as this one. It's surprisingly refreshing to find a fanfic that is actually comparable to the books themselves. Those are a dying bunch, and the best ones are only updated very rarely ... so that makes you the best there is! :D -Xan |
CastusAlbusCor chapter 22 . 3/9/2003 DONE! Finshed the Triology. and it did keep me busy for a while. Now off to the one 19 years later. Albus |
CastusAlbusCor chapter 1 . 3/9/2003 Hm. Muggle Friends, I never saw that comming. I think I'll get to the rest later, but Chapter 2 here I come. Albus |
Oh chapter 22 . 1/25/2003 I have read your this entire series of fanfics and never have you failed too amaize me. You made harry powerful but not to powerful. You made them all human and not characters that always acted this way and never made mistakes. Through all of this you mananged too keep my attention and my bottem on the edge of my seat, suprising me at every turn, and, to all of that, I say this. There is no other way to put it but: YOU ARE A FANFIC GOD! |
BrokenpenBleedingLead chapter 22 . 1/22/2003 I cant' wait for the next all the best luck |
Heart O'fire chapter 1 . 1/14/2003 Nice fic cant wait to see what else you come up with. |