This is so good and I can’t wait to read more of it, hope you updated soon

3

I hope you continue to writing this story. I can't wait for the next chapter. please update soon

Bilbo is already changing little things, but he doesn't realise it yet

Love the changes, how the conversation goes informing Bilbo of the Quest now the Dwarves know he hasn't been fully filled in. And Balin arrived first! Love the spread Bilbo served, and the fact you raised one thing l have thought for ages, that the Dwarves hadn't had a good square meal in a while, nor stayed somewhere they felt safe enough to really relax.

I didn't think you were coming back

Pretty great chapter. Looking forward to the next one.

Great chapter. Love the changes you are making. It gets boring to read the same journey over and over again. I was wondering how bilbo would get the ring. You answered in a most dramatic way. Thank you for writing

We all know Bilbo is not dead but please stop beating the Hobbit. He's small and of weak body (But strong spirit!)

Can't wait for next chapter and Bilbo telling them about his ascendant!

Let me guess.
Gollum's in the next chapter, isn't he?

Awesome chapter 5, I loved it.

Dani

Interesting story, I like it.

Dani

Can't believe Bilbo tried to shame Elrond. Bad form. The only thing he did was not give the Dwarrow meat. It doesn't excuse their behavior. Indeed he showed Bilbo nothing but care and kindness for a lifetime.

Ouch. I would be so upset too. Of course there’s a price but why must three still die?! T-T

(smirks)
If this is how the dwarves react upon learning Bilbo's age, I wonder how they would respond if it were me...
I'm 25, btw!