Thank you for a very enjoyable chapter.

Please please please please update soon! This is a beautiful story so far and I cannot wait to read how she interacts with the fellowship!

This is better?

if you aren't going to make her immortal you should pair her with faramir or eomer

You know you could always update on the weekends and during summer you know when there isn't school. Do hurry I like the story but just having three chapters for two years is kinda disappointing. So please update soon.

Andromeda and Legolas pairing please.

Please keep writing I love this story

it's good, please keep updating!

can't wait to read more!

The story is going nicely. I really hope Andromeda hooks up with Legolas! That would be awesome! Update soon!

I love the legolas/andy idea!

It's really good so far :)

I think it's off to a great start. I was a little curious when you would drop her in and it seems like it's before they meet Aragorn. That's exciting, I can't wait to see when she meets Black Riders. Or the council meeting in Rivendell and how the men of the council will react to get being a woman, assuming she is invited to attend.

On a side note when I read that she spent $600 in one store the cheap side of me cringed... If it were me (granted she's a warrior and knows how to survive) I would get a survival book, camping supplies, extra clothing, sewing supplies, and buy gold things (I assume that's what's gonna be traded in M.E based on what I recall seeing in the movies and just the time period in general). Then watch as the survival book fails me when in a different world, haha.

Anyways it was a good chapter and I can't wait to read more. Good luck with your writing.

Thank you guys for reading, and any helpful critiquing is always welcome. I had thought about setting her up with Eomer, too. It would be such an interesting pairing, but it isn't set in stone yet.

This is very interesting so far. I'm not usually sold on the thought of a sister to Percy but this is actually fitting rather nicely. I also like that its solely Andy going to Middle Earth. I can't wait to see how she reacts to being there, I mean its gotta be a shock when she actually gets there. Also I don't know if you're open to suggestions for pairings but I'd say either Legolas or Éomer (Eoywn's brother). I'm a personal fan of Legolas but whatever you wanna do you should do it.

I hope you update soon and good luck writing.

This is honestly really good, I can't wait for the next update! This story is super good!