This is fantastic. Thanks for posting.

Oh, you had me crying . . . but it is very, very well done. Thank You!

think im going to cry now, that was wonderful!

I'm a huge sucker for angst fics but usually, I need a happy ending to be my light at the end of the dark tunnel. Unfortunately, this fic didn't have a happy ending. However, the tragic ending doesn't detract from quality of this story, which only goes to show the uncommon superiority of this fic.

*flashes a thumbs up* Awesome job on this!

oh my friggin god this fic was so good and so sad and oh! i need to stop blubbering incoherently. You write such wonderfully poignant malcolm/hoshi fics!

and I LOVE all the flashbacks in the fic!

I thought I'd be mad at hoshi for making that bargain but then after some consideration, I decided i could understand her decision. She can't live without malcolm.

I wish malcolm hadn't died but the way he went WAS very admirable and heroic. (T_T) oh u need to write more malcolm/hoshi fics and this time, give the fics a happy ending!

This fic was truly incredible. I usually stay away from angst and probably will from now on because this one IS IT for me. It's perfect, as far as angst goes. I love your style of writing, the humor, the emotion, everything. I can see each of the characters perfectly the way you write them. I wish you'd write more Enterprise fics seeing as how you haven't in a while. Really amazing.

Thats one of the best ff stories i have ever red...thank you and keep on writing (:-))

biro

I'm so glad I found this on ffnet! I've been dying to comment on this story ever since I read it on LDnet. Fabulous. This story just took my breath away! _

This is the most beautiful R/S fic I've ever read, even though it's a deathfic. It's sad, funny, angsty, romance-y... you name it. Really really well written. Thanks so much.
...may I archive it at my Enterprise fanfiction site? It's still under construction, but I hope to be finished soon. If you're interested, I'd give you the URL.
T'eyla

That was incredible. Start to finish. I liked the way the chapters alternated, one moving forward, the other moving back. And yes, the poetry of the chapter headings. I wish, very much, that Malcolm had had a different way, but it was so like him. If there's any romance couple in Trek I can tolerate it's Reed/Sato. You had me in tears with this one. Rolling down my face. Have you considered posting to .creative?

damn, now i'm going to cry, but what happened to t'pol?(had to ask, my fav charac, you know?)

I love this story. Every time I read it, my heart bursts. It is really sad. A very orginal story.

And it has a nice twist. Just before the climax, you have that "will he or won't he moment". It's a very hard thing to pull off, but you did so beautifully

I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU DID THAT!

I am practically in tears - god, that was good...

I loved this story and while I'm a sucker for happy endings, this was well done.

I really liked your story, but what I truely loved was the poem that you wrote for the chapter titles. It was amazingly beautiful. As I kept coming back to read your updates, I'd read through the poem. I loved it, and I'm not really into poetry, so it's even more impressive! Well done!