I- i LOVE THIS STORY SO MUCH. the way you portray past Hook and all his delicious devilish-ness. Cant wait for the updates.
Maybe Emma just has to go through something dangerous that would somehow push the magic out of her lol idk

This has been wonderful to read so far! I love how you've spun this divergence from canon whilst also bringing so many elements of their first history into it, but many of them in reverse. The cycliclical nature of the timeline (rather than intersecting or linear) is really clever and huge kudos to you for pulling it off so well :)

Its really great to see the differences in the version of Killian from 28 years ago. Nicely balanced to bring out more of the pirate without losing who he ultimately is beneath it. And of course, the fact that they can't help their attraction regardless of time or space is just beautiful.

This is really wonderful and I've gotten completely immersed in it so its quite devastating to see its not been updated in some time. I realise life gets busy and inspiration can be fickle, but I do hope you one day find the time or inspiration to continue this. It deserves an ending and I'd love to see where it goes :) Great work, regardless!

I realize its been a year since you've updated (it's always the worse when you find an INCREDIBLE fic and know that it probably wont ever be finished.) I really, really hope that you find this and decide to grace us with the ending! It's brilliantly written and very original! LOVE! I'm following and favoriting JUST in case you decide to start back up. xoxo - E

This is really good

I do hope the muse feels inclined to help you continue this story.

I love this story so much already! I dearly hope you finish it whenever you have time, I'd love to read the rest of it.
I think she should get help from the Dark One! It would really force Killian to take sides. And he would prove yet again how much faith he has in Emma if he's willing to work with Rumple in exchange for an uncertain future. I'm not saying it won't be hard to write but it would totally be interesting. And it would make sense in the future why Hook seems to always be willing to give so much for her, maybe she can make some sacrifices along the way too?
Ok I clearly got carried away, I just really loved your story.
Hope you keep writing and if not, thank you for what you already wrote.
-M

Well, technically she already has her magic back, but maybe she just needs to realize that? Maybe a TLK?

Hey, I love your story, your take on the whole thing is really interesting and it is well written. I can't wait to see how it is going to evolve.

Love it you need to post the next chapter soon I'm living in suspense!

I adore this story and highly anticipate each new chapter. Thank you for writing it.

Well, I think she could try the fairies anyway because they might believe her and point her in the right direction where to go bit overall the wand brought her home so unless a magic bean and her magic make a future portal I can't see any other way other than trying Rumpelstiltskin.

MoreMoreMore!

Love it! Please write more as soon as you can!

I missed this story so much and was so excited to see it's return. This is such a fantastic story. You have done such a great job with this. Thank you so much for gracing us with its presence. The dynamic between Hook and Emma is and it's fascinating to see it play out in the past, especially considering that Hook is his past self and has no memory of Emma or his love for her. I love that his attraction for her still stands and that Emma cannot deny her own attraction to him. The fact that she finally realized that she's in love with the pirate is rewarding as well. And that passionate kiss between these two was phenomenal. Your writing ability is amazing, and I enjoyed every moment of this chapter. Very good form.

Aww
Love