Excellent fic, and I’m not even a fan of Doctor Who. I really appreciate the actual happy ending - I can’t really enjoy a story without one, so the fact that everyone involved in this fic git their happy ending in the end.

This fic seems to have gone under the radar of the tagged fandoms, and that’s a crime, since I’m doubting that I’ll find a Madoka crossover so compelling ever again.

Well done.

I got the RWBY references, but didn't find the others when I tried Googling. Nice reference to Weiss preferring apples. I don't think that ever comes up in canon, but I hope they aren't poisoned.

Fun Note:
Ellie and Annie are pretty clearly Elsa and Anna from Frozen. Frozen was based on the tale of the Snow Queen, with Elsa as the titular Queen.
Weiss Schnee has a sister named Winter. Winter is predicted to be based on the tale of the Snow Queen.
We don't just have 2 Ice Queens. We have THE Snow Queen... TWICE! Imagine if they met. Awkward...
About as awkward as Rena "Cendrillon" Minami from Magia Record meeting Cinder "Cinderella" Fall from RWBY.

This... was... beautiful! Bravo! that's literally all i can think of right now, just Bravo

That was a wild, INCREDIBLY satisfying ride, and I hope to one day write something as moving and well-crafted. Kudo 1050

my god, I did not realize that while I'm writing I'm crying, this story was great the best crossover of magical girls and doctor who, I've seen in my life, if I'm honest This story made me cry more than expected, I mean I'm preventing my tears from falling on the phone as I write this,I took it by surprise but I loved the best I've read and that is short even more impressive, great development and a great story in little chapters.
You have a good day . Stay with hope and determination

I just can't get to the end. I guess that the Doctor Who stuff us just isn't for me. I wonder why so many western characters wind up being such Grau Stu's?

...¡EXCELENTE GRAN FANFIC!...¡A SIDO EL MEJOR DE LOS QUE E LEIDO!...¡MUCHAS GRACIAS POR EL FIC...ES BUENO SABER QUE MADOKA TUVO UN LINDO Y FELIZ FINAL!...

Wow. what an awesome story! so sweet and well done!

Hi! I loved your story. There is so much to say about it: the plot and the characterization are amazing. For example, I thought the friendship between Donna and Kyoko was touching. In my opinion, that's why Donna is the perfect companion for this story.

I also loved the Doctor in this. On one hand, we get to see his good side (he helps the girls and save Donna's life) and on the other hand, we are reminded that you'd better not anger him (the Incubators learned that the hard way).

I also liked all the Easter eggs from Doctor Who and the other shows even if I didn't know all of them.

Good chapter.

Typical the doctors A plain failed.

I thing with the number of magical girls lowering is a little ominous.

Lastly I think the doctor may want to talk to Mami about loneliness considering he is the expert of that.

Good chapter.

However, I think Homura may have been a little to trusting.

Now here comes the doctor as a teacher, or a janitor.

I gotta absolutely say, even if I am mostly unfamiliar with the Doctor Who series, I really, really loved this fic, especially the endings!
Happy endings are always good!

even though it may take you a few hours to read this story it is well worth it read this story on a five-star scale this story gets 100 stars

I loved this. The ending just felt...so right that I just felt like tearing up in happiness for them. The story overall was amazing, and I think it deserves a little more recognition for those unfamiliar with crossovers. Your structure was spot on, and no one felt really out of character. You made a huge battle field scene work so well and ended the story with a peaceful end while not having it feel to rushed. I don't have any real complaints on this, and I would probably recommend this story for people who have both watched and enjoyed these series.

Absolutely wonderful, now someone has to animate this in flash/steam/whatever