Great alt reality. I like the idea especially for Sam. Love the puppy. Would love to see more about that.

Oh man, I love your take on the boys and the beautifully thought out house and this whole concept and the fire sneezing puppy. This is lovely.

Very sweet. I hope Team Free Will gets a happy ending when all is done, and this is a warm fuzzy possibility. :)

Oh wow this was a gift-wrapped package of a bunch of things I didn't know I wanted(except for the Sam getting a dog part; I knew I wanted that, though the half-Hellhound was a nice surprise). Thank you for writing this!

Oh man...that was great. I almost want you to write a sequel. Except that I can't think of what you'd add.

I am going to cry, this is so beautiful...

*Cries*

This was amazing, amazing. I've been a fan of your Sherlock stuff for a long time and I was freaking excited when I saw you had branched into Supernatural. I was definitely not disappointed. Your usual skill as a very clear and thoughtful writer came through awesomely. This was such a sweet story too-the gift Dean gives Sam, the sense of family, and the fulfillment of what I always thought was Sam's really true dream-to get out of hunting. You write Sam SO well-intelligent, thoughtful, caring, and very capable. I love how many details you add to show how much knowledge Sam really has. I wish the show would let us see as much of his intelligence as you do:). Very, very awesome.

I am very irritated that you've branched into supernatural, primarily because your fics are so dang good that they've seduced me into Star Trek TOS as well even more Sherlock (which I already knew and fangirled over). And I really don't have time to start marathoning Supernatural before school starts in the fall... T_T
Finally got a account so now I can officially say: you're one of my favourite fanfiction authors ever, and I've reread your stuff more than is healthy for my courseload at school D. I love the flow of your writing (and that you have mad editing skillz) and your characterization is superb.
I will continue reading your stuff whatever you write (even supernatural *heavy sigh*); keep up the awesome and amazing fics!

I really enjoyed this, well done! Also while I'm at it, I am an avid fan of your writing, especially your Star Trek fanfiction. You write amazingly well; you stay so close to character and yet still put in your own personal touches! So yeah. Awesome.

THIS IS THE BEST THING EVER I'M DYING THANK YOU A THOUSAND THOUSAND TIMES FOR WRITING THIS /THANK YOU/.

I've never watched "Supernatural" but I couldn't resist reading all the same. And I still thought it was lovely, with characters caring for each other. Plus the half-hellhound puppy sounds adorable (if somewhat dangerous.)

. . . Sam's new house has a full library with a fireplace and one of those librarian ladders for his bookshelves. Can I live there too please?!

I literally just started season one of Supernatural today, so I don't quite get all the references and holy shit this is so far down the line for me, but this was a cute story. It'd be fun to see Sam and his Hell puppy (please tell me the dog gets an awesome name like Blaze (for the fire sneezes) or something) settling in and making me the place their own. Preferably something in the kitchen that involves Sam trying to make dinner before Dean shows up and tries to 'help'.

Oh my gosh. So much love for this story.

Oh My Goodness, that was incredible!

I have to say, I almost passed his over, the summary of Sam getting hous real k y sounding like my thing. I am so, so glad I didn't.

You tied so much up so nicely, intertwining their past with what is happening now.

This would be such a great way for them to end the Show.

OMG.. the thing with the puppy.. what Dean said about the puppy not being a monster.. the double meaning behind those words..

*wipes away tears*

So beautiful .. If only THIS would really happen..

*cries*