I've read quite a few of your stories, but this one was one of the hardest to read, and kinda broke my heart. The way you write Sam and Dean's relationship is perfect.

Oh my Chuck, my heart.

WOW! Heavy duty and beautiful! Season5 was a tough one and a story like this helps out it back into perspective. Thank you so much!

Hadn't thought about those words - I'm not going to let you die - from Lucifer, until something like this happens. Crazy lady, scary lady, badass lady. Yeow! Lucifer bringing Sam back, over and over again - this was, literally, hell on earth for Sam. somewhat for Dean, not being able to keep Sam protected. Glad Cas could help Dean find Sam as fast as he could. Can't imagine Sam's nightmares from THIS hunt. Great story, will never forget.

OMG, totally horrifying that a human could do that, and, like Dean had to be grateful to Lucifer that he wouldn't let Sam die, though it enabled Claire to torture and kill him again and again and again. Loved Sam's strength that he held out and wouldn't give in to letting Lucifer know where he was despite knowing he would be tortured again. Had to smile that Castiel dealt with Claire. And so believable Sam's meltdown when he was back at the motel and realised he was safe and it was over.
Brilliant story.

Loved it! Soooooo much!

Amazing job, man :)

I can't believe I'm about 3 stories behind! Got caught up in the one shots :O). I love being able to feed my addiction!

Wow. Lucifer the scumbag! Bringing poor Sam back just to get killed again. Very good. I liked reading it. Protective Dean is awesome!

F***********ing LOVED IT! Write something like this again.

This was horrifying and riveting. Well done.

Very well done.

nice :)

Wow! Creepy and cringe-worthy .. and very well written. Excellent plot as well. Great (and very true to form) interaction in the library as Dean is teasing Sam, as well as the growing terror as Dean realizes Sam is gone. Poor Sam, but I particularly loved the reunion! Thanks so much for posting!

Poor Sam, going through that was so horrible. I liked how you had this set up and how Dean was not giving up. I’m glad that Castiel was able to help out Dean and together they were able to find him.