Really good job.

I have yet to read anything that changes my opinion that Castle should have ran as far away from Kate Beckett as he could and never looked back.

I like when Josh is the bad guy but I do have one issue with this scenario. I really don't think Castle would back off in that instance and lie about it being Josh. Would he really think Kate would ever be happy with someone capable of stabbing him? Instead I think he would fear for her safety first. Then he would guide her to discover who it was even if he couldn't face telling her point blank.

Nice...really nice. You have 'solved the Josh dilemma'...so, when will you begin to 'rid us of 3XK'? Honestly, this is a superb one-shot. Thanks!

That was honestly ridiculous. And I hate when Josh is pictured as an ass whereas he wasn't.

Yeah, Josh is going to prison. Sorry Castle had to get hurt for it. I loved it.

This was a very enjoyable read. Thank you.

Loved it. Thanks.

I enjoyed this view of the situation and found it to be very plausible. Please, please go back through your story and proof it for spelling errors and punctuation. Some of your sentences are extremely long and need to be two sentences. The words 'your' and 'you're' are totally different meanings and you see to use them interchangeably. Please get a beta, the story idea is good but the grammar is not.

The bartender's names make me think of one of my favorite Country singers, Jake Owen. Good choice of names. This is the first story I've read of Josh's reaction to Kate returning from LA with Castle. I never really liked Josh, so I'm happy he is going to prison. Well done.