This was an amazing story. I am *truly* surprised at how many tears I shed reading it. Maybe it was the emotional moment or maybe the utter disappointment of never getting to see these two even kiss on the show but I'd wager it a mix of both. This is hands down my favorite of this ship. Thank you.

What! You can't end it here :-) please, please finish. I mean what happens next? Does Abbie succumb to Caroline? Or, do Abbie and Crane live happily ever after?

I need more of this!

Great work. Lovely read

I love your writing. On to chapter 5 now!

The author said she has another chapter coming, I hope we get it. I still want more of Abbie and Ichabod. Do they eventually move in together, have babies, I need to know.

This is adorable! I can't wait for the next chapter. You're really good at showing exactly how complex their relationship is. Nice work.

Where's the epilogue?! I need it... I need it bad!

Please finish your story

Well there's no other word that I can think of to describe Abbie this chapter other than she was a b*tch. And for the record I really like her but in situations like this she should've ended it honestly because lies hurt more than the truth.

Also something like this is something that I'd never do because I'd never want to experience it - someone who's only with you because you're easily/readily available - thus only means that 'don't do unto others what you don't want others to do unto you'.

Sorry I got a bit passionate about it. Hehe, but this is what I really think.

I'm in love with this story! The icabbie moments in this makes me smile like an idiot. I hope you update soon :)

Can't wait for the epilogue. I have thoroughly enjoyed this story. I hope you do some more Sleepy Hollow.

What's romance without a little hurt feelings? Loved this. I mean, I hated that Crane hurt Abbie's feelings, but it was well-done. I really do love this story!

Fuck, indeed! That was incredibly hot, but also sweet and realistic. Your first time writing smut? I don't believe it. Let me re-read to be sure. :)

This is hitting me in my rom-com sweet spot.