Exceptional story, I can’t stop crying and it’s already been a good half hour ! This was beautiful and SO SO sad !

you know how there's fanfics of the Percy Jackson crew reading other fanfics as if it's an alternate timeline? Id would love one for this fic on this chapter alone . holy shit this was amazing ! and so funny ! I've read this fic through once already but I came back to read this chapter specifically bc I love it. I can't wait to read the next chapter of the sequel when you decide to post it!

I love your endings !

I love the ending

Fic was good but Percy becoming the way he has, despising Annabeth and having affections for Nico is plain stupid to be honest sorry

It’s been years since I’ve read this story. The last time... was it 2016? I could be wrong. I was just scrolling through Pinterest bored out of my mind when for some reason I remembered this story and decided to see if my fan account still worked. Anyway, this was my absolutely favorite fan fiction back in middle school and I remember always waiting for you to update. Can you imagine how much I screamed when, now a Junior in high school, I found that you had updated again? Haha it’s amazing. Thank you so much for this journey to my childhood again. It’s been such a pleasure.

I just. Cant deal with this. I’m literally crying right now (since chapter 45-ish i haven’t been able to stop crying). CN you update just maybe one more chapter? Cause, REALLY!? Is Nico really dead? How will Percy deal with his loss and overall trauma? And, ARE THEY GONNA END UP TOGETHER OR NOT!?
At fist I though this story was finished, and hey, maybe it is, but please, for the sake of your readers, update one more time please! (Whenever you can, of course. When you have the time) because this was a beautiful story and it made me cry just like the book did. You managed to make it more... real, in a way that made me realize that Tartarus really his hell on hearth, and that it really damaged our heroes. And I loved that you brought the concept of love in the meadle of such gore and nightmerish situations. So amazing story, and I hope you finish it sometime! I’ll be waiting
Hope Nico is alive.

Please update! Please!

Y Gay? Meh watever u good.

thanks for breaking my heart it's been a wild ride I'm still screaming from the feels

God this chapter was a bit heartbreaking and it’s definit a favorite. Because you’re not restricted to being PG you definitely took advantage of making the trip down Tartarus really horrific and it’s paid off. Some of the things you wrote really hit how hard demigods have it. I really loved this chapter. Great job

You’ve seriously made me cry! Nico’s love for Percy is just so encompassing and sad! I can feel Nico’s pain and his sacrifice and it hurts! Please update! Will Nico die or will he live? Nico is the one demigod that deserves a happy ending above all the others!

AHHHHHHHHHH!

Please update!

I was so excited to see so many chapters published in one day! I finally had time to read them and read it in one sitting! I’m dying to read the next chapter!

...why do i always do this to myself? i love this story so much, holy shit. it's 6:23 in the morning, i have school in an hour and i've been sitting on my bed for the better part of the night ripping my hair out about how awesome this story is. i'm legitimately crying rn (nico, you self-sacrificing fuck - i knew this shit was coming and i'm still crying). i don't know what i expected when i opened this story but somehow, you've managed to hit all of my ugly shipper feelings in exactly the right way. i think this might be my favorite percico fic on this site. i can't wait to see the next chapter because holy fuck, i know you didn't just kill off my boy (even if you did, that kiss was honestly so worth it - you nailed the characterization of both of them and i just...i'm overwhelmed rn)

(i also just wanted to add that i've literally always been so intrigued by this entire concept and i'm so glad someone wrote it - that's not me because i definitely would've fucked it up - and that the story itself is actually so good and well-written. god, i have to get ready for school now but this was awesome and i'll probably be thinking about it for the rest of the day.)

I like the story very much. It’s different from others and that makes me enjoy it more. Nice work.