Yay, a kiss! So exciting to get an update for this story! Thank you!

This seems a wonderful story

I really liked this chapter! Minerva having a panic attack was very interesting. I loved that the memory that got her out of it was of the night she met Gandalf. I ship these two so much and love that you are continuing this story again! I am super excited to read what comes next!

This is an excellent story! I’m glad I finally chose to read it after all these years. Love the nice blending between the two fandoms.

This was PERFECT. This is what I have been HOPING FOR all along. Their conversation, OMG. I got goosebumps. The feeling, such raw emotions. They are both the one other look up to, so they had to remain strong, pretend to be well even if their hearts are breaking inside.

Ga adored Frodo. It broke him to have to trust this mission to him, who was like a grandson to him. And Mc, when she mentioned Neville, OMG, I just got so many flash backs.

I'm so glad they finally had the time to pause for a moment, to look at themselves and have an open conversation. This is what was needed, and you haven't disappointment. I'll be waiting to read more, my friend. You have undone yourself with this chapter.

OMG! This chapter was awesome. The encountered between our dear group and the Rohan riders is one of my favorites in the movie. I loved how Mc jumped to defend Gi along Le. It served to see how far they have come, and how much M has come to care for all of them.

AND THE BEST, BEST, BEST. I could feel Mc's heart breaking and then putting itself together again when Ga appeared. He apologized, as he should have. It was so sweet how he embraced her.

Oh, I also loved the part when Mc shocks them showing Le, Gi and Ar her animagous power. They acted so curious about this brand of magic unknown to them. And then, of course, they reached Rohan and Ga saved the King, who is one of my favorite characters. He is flawed, proud like all kings, but a good person at heart. Can't wait to see more.

In general, this was a great chapter. It is long, your description are outstanding and it flows very well. Kudos to you, my friend!

This story is great and I hope you update again!

So excited to see an update! Thank you! Interesting back story, and I'm eager to see where there future will lead!

I'm loving the juxtaposition of these stories! Can't wait to see where you take it!

I cant't wait more the next chapter

Very good work, more please

I’m so happy there is a new chapter! I love the reunion between Minerva and Gandalf. Their conversation while riding to Rohan was great. I loved when she leaned her head back just to hear him, it was super sweet. I’m so happy they’re back together! I cannot wait for more!

Nice one :)

Omg THIS WAS SUCH A GREAT CHAPTER! I love this so much. I am so happy you updated, I reread the whole story and It’s just as amazing as the first time I read it. I love Gandalf and Minerva so much. I can’t wait for more! Especially for Minerva to be with Gandalf again.

Thank you very much for updating.
I have loved your story, due to his originality in the pairing, but also I like how you make the LOTR story your own, changing some lines and narrating everything differently.
I like McGonagall and Gandalf a lot and I love the pairing in that way, however I am worried about how that relationship could have a future, specially for Gandalf, since he is immortal as he is Olorin the maia, who participated in the song of creation of Arda.