| Reviews for Memoirs of an Editor |
|---|
remadora-ftw chapter 1 . 8/17/2016 oh wow okay I liked this more than I thought I would it's so refreshing to read a castle story not about caskett haha and then about gina like I never spent more than a few minutes thinkg about her I mean I actally did like her as a character in season 3 but yeah idk and oh I like this as an explanation for the name confusion haha yeah this was nice |
Netsrik1 chapter 1 . 6/23/2016 I just found this and I really enjoyed it. Great fix of the whole Cowell/Griffin thing. And thanks for making Gina human. I've always felt that the exes - with the possible exception of Meredith - have gotten a bad rap. Gina does make a good foil in fics, if Castle and Beckett need to be apart, have Gina put Rick in a meeting. But on the whole, she isn't a bad person. Thanks again for the great story! |
potterfanxp123 chapter 1 . 5/12/2015 Good back story for a character that really should have had one if they used her at all. Doctor Motorcycle Boy had a better back story, and I hated him. Great job. Keep up the good work. |
ebfiddler chapter 1 . 3/24/2015 This was great! Love your headcanon for Gina. It goes a long way toward explaining what makes this character tick. |
nighttimerunner chapter 1 . 8/16/2014 Wow. I originally skipped this story, because I had no time. And also because I wasn't the least bit interested in Gina's inner musings. She's always seemed so cold and I think you explained brilliantly why that could be. Thank you for the tip. Reading this was really helpful. Now I feel ready to tackle your prompt. ;) |
fembot79 chapter 1 . 2/20/2014 Amazing! Lou, you are such a capable writer! This piece just blew me away. You took a minor character, outside of our primary storyline, and you gave her such a rich and nuanced backstory that had me really engrossed and wishing for more. I want to know more about Gina Griffith and her struggles in life, love, etc. I'm just so sorry it took me this long to get to this story. You are an amazing writer! Cheers:) Dia |
Lydian Stone chapter 1 . 1/14/2014 Thanks for making that make sense. : ) |
I'm Widget chapter 1 . 1/13/2014 Wow. I didn't expect to like this, but I do. Puts a lot of things into perspective. Thanks! |
BerkieLynn chapter 1 . 1/12/2014 Love this idea. I know that she and Rick were on bad footing at the start of the series but they continued working together so I've never thought that she was an inherently bad person. This a beautiful, humanizing take on a little seen character. |
Ilovetoread09 chapter 1 . 1/12/2014 I really like this little background you did on Gina. We really don't know that much about her beside what has been said on the show. I really liked the explanation of her two last names and how she did like Alexis, even if she wasn't very close with her. Thanks for writing! |
yazzea chapter 1 . 1/12/2014 I don't hate Gina, why would I? She seems like a decent (fictional) human being. I really like how you explained her two last names and characterized her marriage with Castle. I can see how it could have happened that way. Thank you for writing her back story, I enjoyed reading it. |
bluedaisy05 chapter 1 . 1/12/2014 This is great. I'm not sure I ever noticed any disparity in Gina's last name, tbh. I suspect it's more a consequence of a mistake in the writer's room, but I think this is a great headcanon to cover that up. I'm probably one of a few people in the fandom who actually likes Gina, so it was great to see someone delve into her backstory a bit. Awesome job! |
purplangel chapter 1 . 1/12/2014 This is truly wonderful, Louise. I love how your mind thinks. I can seriously see this mirroring Marlowe's thoughts of Gina. I actually quite like Geoffrey and how he saw a spark of drive & determination in the young, just graduated college graduate. Luv that he offered her an internship and how they had to hide their relationship and yes, rumors would fly around about Gina sleeping her way to the top. That's a given with the territory. So sad about the affair though, but so true to life. Such a unique story here on FF. Remarkable actually. Very Believable. Thank U. |
spottedpony chapter 1 . 1/12/2014 Beautiful story. I've always wondered about Gina's story. I don't think it has been explored much on the show leaving room for a story just like this. I thought you tied the little pieces we do know about Gina and Rick's relationship wonderfully. Thanks for providing a background that is realistic and characteristic. Loved it! Bravo, Lisa |
RoninBlackwing chapter 1 . 1/12/2014 I like it. I've never understood the negative portrayals of Gina given we were never show anything to support them. In fact she is probably the least objectionable person to get between Castle and Beckett. For whatever reason Beckett's boyfriends, pre-show included, all came off as a bit too full of themselves and if I were to start on the problems with every woman that got involved with Castle during the run of the show I'd run out of space. So it's nice to see a fic that show this woman as something other than a monster or the living incarnation of evil. |