La nueva directora de St. Bernandette hace participar el colegio en el concurso "Dramaturgo escolar" con la esperanza de ganar el dinero suficiente para actualizar el colegio. Pone a cargo a la nueva maestra de música y el gruñón profesor de lenguaje, que se muestra reacio a la novata maestra. Pero nunca esperaría que ella tuviera la ocurrencia de producir una "obra del mal".

Hey!" Donald said as he shoved his hands in his pockets. "Hello." Roderick nodded. "Still like to talk proper then?" "Yeah. Still with Sarah then?" "Yeah and our little boys, Lenny and Scottie." Roderick and Donald see each other 4 years later at their dad's funeral. P.s. Roderick never went to the barn at the end of the movie in this version

Mr. Maddens is single at Christmas again and has gone back to his old ways of loathing the holiday. It seems his days of putting on the Nativity are over. That is until he meets the new teacher Miss Finley and offers to help her put on the best play ever!